District Court of Appeal of Florida July 28, 1967, No. 845 (Pitts v. Pitchford)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-07-1967

MacMILLAN, HUGH, Associate Judge.

This appeal involves a suit against the maker by an administrator of the estate of the decedent payee on four promissory notes marked “L.S.” in ink after the maker’s signature. Three notes were dated in 1949, of which two were payable 60 days after date and the third 1 year after date. The fourth note was dated September 20, 1950, and was payable 2 years after date. Suit was filed on October 19, 1964, requesting a trial by jury and alleging the notes were under seal. In his answer, the defendant-maker admitted executing the notes, but denied they were under seal when he executed them and asserted that any action thereon is barred by the statute of limitations.

In the trial, the application of the “Dead Man’s Statute”, F.S.A. § 90.05, was raised as to the admissibility of testimony by the maker as to whether the notes were under seal when executed. The trial court permitted such testimony on the theory that, if the genuineness of signatures thereto were questioned, such testimony would not be barred, and, thus, a similar rule should apply to the question of the validity of seals on the notes. Testimony was also admitted to the effect that the maker did not sub*564sequently have knowledge of the seals on the notes nor did he authorize anyone to make such notations after his signature. If the notes were under seal, the same would then be a specialty and the statute of limitations of 20 years would apply under F.S.A. § 95.11(1), and if not under seal, then the 5-year statute of limitations would apply under F.S.A. § 95.11(3).

The jury found for the defendant, and the plaintiff-administrator (appellant) first appealed to the Florida Supreme Court, and thereafter the case was referred to this court for disposition. We affirm.

The Supreme Court of Florida in the case of Small v. Shure, Fla. 1957, 94 So.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.