District Court, S.D. Texas August 24, 1967, No. 66-G-12 (United States v. Tug Otto)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-08-1967

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER:

NOEL, District Judge.

This is an action brought by the United States under the Rivers and Harbors Act, 33 U.S.C. § 408,1 to recover damages to Texas City .Channel Lighted Buoy #6 (“Buoy #6”), and for the assessment of a penalty under 33 U.S.C. §§ 411 and 412.2

Initially, the suit was directed against the Alamo Water Transportation Co. in personam and the Tug Otto and Barge Alamo 600 in rem. The in personam action against Alamo Water Transportation Co., owner of said barge and tug, has been severed for later disposition, and the Tug Otto has been dismissed from this proceeding at the request of libellant.

On May 11, 1962, while the Tug Otto and Barge Alamo 600 were making a turn from the Intracoastal Waterway into the Texas City Ship Channel, a strong outgoing tide caused the bow of the Barge Alamo 600 to be set against Buoy #6, an aid to navigation and established mark owned by the United States. The person in charge of the Tug Otto radioed the Coast Guard station that the barge had just “run over” a buoy. The same day, Coast Guard personnel were sent to survey the damage to the buoy.

Chief Petty Officer Connie L. Wilson, who accompanied the Coast Guard inspection group, testified on behalf of the government that Buoy #6 was found to be fifty yards off its charted position. Wilson inspected the buoy and saw that *1132the paint work on the buoy body was scarred down to the metal. The buoy body on the side next to the battery pocket was “caved in” approximately eight or ten inches deep, two or three feet wide, and three or four feet in length. The seam of the buoy body was cracked about a foot or so, and two pieces of angle iron had been torn loose from the deck.

Wilson testified that he was not allowed to open the battery pocket without prior approval from his superior, and did not inspect the batteries until the Coast Guard unit returned a week or ten days later to relieve the buoy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.