Louisiana Court of Appeal April 19, 1968, 7226 (Catalanotto v. Associates Discount)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-04-1968
207 So.2d 180 (1968) Emile CATALANOTTO v. ASSOCIATES DISCOUNT. No. 7226. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, First Circuit. January 29, 1968. Rehearing Denied March 4, 1968. Writ Refused April 19, 1968. *181 Charles B. W. Palmer, of Palmer & Palmer, Amite, for appellant. Robert A. Hawthorne, of Sanders, Miller, Downing & Kean, Baton Rouge, for appellee. Before LANDRY, REID and BAILES, JJ. LANDRY, Judge. This appeal by plaintiff, Emile Catalanotto, is from the judgment of the trial court dismissing appellant's demand against defendant, Associates Discount Corporation (Associates) for damages for alleged wrongful seizure of plaintiff's automobile *182 via executory process, pursuant to defendant's exception of no cause of action. We find the trial court properly resolved the legal issues herein presented for resolution. It is settled jurisprudence that an exception of no cause of action addresses itself to the legal sufficiency of plaintiff's petition and the exhibits thereto attached and is therefore triable on the face of the papers. Joyce v. Brothers Realty Co., La. App., 127 So.2d 756. Equally well established is the principle that in determining the validity of an exception of no cause of action, all well pleaded allegations of plaintiff's petition must be accepted as true. Call v. Huffman, La.App., 163 So.2d 397. Narration of certain undisputed background information is essential to a proper understanding of the questions of law presented upon this appeal. On December 16, 1962, appellant bought an automobile from Robinson Bros., Inc., pursuant to which appellant executed a chattel mortgage and promissory note securing payment of the unpaid portion of the agreed purchase price. The note and chattel mortgage were executed under private signature and signed by appellant and a named representative of the aforesaid vendor. In addition, the face of the chattel mortgage bears the signatures of W. H. Robinson and Mabel Maloy, as witnesses.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit