Hawaii Supreme Court November 6, 1968, 4749 (Abraham v. S. E. Onorato Garages)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-11-1968

*629

OPINION OF THE COURT BY

LEVINSON, J.

The plaintiff-appellant brought this action for damages alleged to have resulted from injuries sustained by her while she was a passenger in a Mustang automobile driven by one Everett McCoy during the early morning hours of December 18, 1964. McCoy had taken the vehicle from the Marks Center Garage in Honolulu, of which he was manager, and he did so without permission from the owner of the Mustang (hereinafter Owner), who had stored the car there, and without authority from his employer, defendant-appellant S. E. Onorato Garages (hereinafter Onorato).

McCoy was first employed by Onorato on July 13, 1961, as a parking attendant for St. Mary’s Square Garage in San Francisco. At the time his employment commenced, Onorato learned that McCoy had a valid driver’s license, that he was well recommended by his last employer, and that he was bondable under the blanket insurance policy issued to Onorato. Unknown to Onorato, McCoy had a record of criminal convictions as follows: joyriding as a juvenile seventeen years earlier; assault and battery four years earlier; and the hit and run of a parked vehicle nine months earlier. On March 4, 1963 McCoy was promoted to the position of night manager of the Portsmouth Square Garage in San Francisco. After performing well in that position for approximately nineteen months, he was transferred to Honolulu on October 12, 1964 to become the manager of the Marks Center Garage.

*630

During 'his period of employment with Onorato and up to the time of his transfer to Honolulu, McCoy’s driver’s license had been suspended at various times, primarily for failure to present proof of financial responsibility to the proper authorities as required by the California law. Shortly before his transfer to Honolulu, he was convicted for driving while his license was suspended, with the result that his license was suspended for an additional six months.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.