Arizona Supreme Court November 7, 1968, 9285-PR (Brooker v. Canny)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-11-1968

McFARLAND, Chief Justice:

This case is before us on a petition for review of a decision of the Court of Appeals reversing a judgment of the Superior Court in favor of defendant. 7 Ariz.App. 337, 439 P.2d 309.

Plaintiff Frederick Brooker sued defendant Catherine Canny for injuries received when the pick-up truck he was driving was struck by an automobile driven by defendant. Plaintiff was going north on Palo Christi Road, and attempted to turn left into a private drive. Defendant, who was driving north behind plaintiff, attempted to pass him just as he made his turn. There was a yellow line in the northbound lane a short distance ahead of the place of the collision. Had both vehicles continued northward, defendant could not have completed passing plaintiff before passing the beginning of the yellow line. The accident occurred in broad daylight.

The jury found for defendant, and judgment was entered for her. Plaintiff appealed.

*531

The principal question argued is the propriety of the following instruction:

“You are instructed that the danger of left-hand turns between intersections is so great that they should not be attempted without the exercise of extra precaution. Left-hand turns by automobiles between intersections are less frequent than at crossings, and naturally are not anticipated to the same extent.”

Plaintiff made a timely objection to this instruction on the ground that it required him to exercise “extra precaution,” and thus placed upon him a standard of extraordinary care, rather than a standard of reasonable care under the circumstances.

In plaintiffs brief before this Court, he also argued that the instruction requiring “extra precaution” upon making a left turn between intersections differs from the one approved in Phoenix Baking Co. v. Vaught, 62 Ariz. 222, 156 P.2d 725, in that the instruction there approved was limited to left-hand turns on “much-traveled highways,” while in the instant case no such limitation was mentioned.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.