California Supreme Court June 3, 1968, L. A. 29097 (People Ex Rel. Roddis v. California Mutual Ass'n)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-06-1968

PETERS, J.

The Insurance Commissioner initiated this action to restrain the individual defendants (organized under the name of California Mutual Association) from carrying on business as an insurer without first securing a certificate of authority pursuant to Insurance Code section 700. The Insurance Commissioner has appealed from a judgment denying the injunction and declaring that respondent was not engaged in conducting an insurance business.

California Mutual Association (hereinafter CMA), a nonprofit unincorporated association, was organized in 1962. It is controlled by the promoters. The subscribing members have no voting power over the business or the policies of the association. Its stated purpose is to make payments in limited amounts for medical and hospital services rendered to its members using funds derived from periodic dues. The trial court found that the business was carried on honestly and that CMA has made all payments promised under the plan.

Subscribing members were primarily enlisted from labor unions. At the start of the trial CMA had about 1,500 members, the number decreased to 1,063 members by the conclusion of the trial.

At the start of the trial, CMA had contracts with 17 physicians who agreed to render services to the members and to

*679

look exclusively to CMA for payment of the scheduled fee, but they reserved the right to charge the member an amount in excess of the specified fee. It was stipulated that a majority of CMA’s members were treated by physicians affiliated with the San Bernardino Foundation for Medical Care and the Riverside Foundation. Although CMA agreed to pay benefits meeting standards set by the foundations, there were no contracts with the individual affiliated doctors, nor was there any arrangement specifying a particular fund for payment.

By the end of the trial, CMA had terminated its contract with the San Bernardino foundation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.