Oregon Supreme Court February 14, 1968 (DeFoor v. Lematta)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-02-1968
GOODWIN, J.
Buben DeFoor was killed in 1964 in a helicopter accident in California as the result of the alleged negligence of the pilot, Marvin Lematta, and Columbia Helicopters, Inc., an Oregon corporation.
Both DeFoor and Lematta were Oregon domiciliares. At the time of the accident Oregon had a “wrongful death” limit of $25,000 (OBS 30.020), while California had no such limit. California had, however, a “willful conduct” guest statute applying to a vehicle owner injured in his own vehicle while it was being driven by another.
①
It was argued that by reason of
*118
a California Public Utility Code provision
②
the California guest statute applied to the accident in question. A third California statute also applied to guest passengers in aircraft.
③
Oregon then had a “gross negligence” guest statute applying to aircraft.
④
The trial court refused to give effect to any of the guest statutes. The jury awarded the plaintiff $36,000. The defendants seek reversal under the California guest statutes or, in the alternative, reduction of the judgment to comply with the Oregon wrongful-death limits.
The relevant facts are as follows: DeFoor, who wanted to buy a helicopter for use in his business in Springfield, Oregon, negotiated with Lematta, a vice president of Columbia, for the purchase of a Hughes
*119
helicopter. The contract was made in Oregon. Delivery was to he taken in Culver City, California. The purchaser was an Oregon corporation controlled by DeFoor. As part of the agreement, Lematta was to teach DeFoor to fly the helicopter. DeFoor agreed to meet Lematta in Culver City. The two planned to fly, at DeFoor’s expense, to Springfield, Oregon, stopping on the way at DeFoor’s ranch near Tonopah, Nevada. The fatal flight deviated from the planned course in that DeFoor requested Lematta to reconnoiter Lake Crowley, on the leeward slope of the Sierra Nevada mountains northwest of Bishop, California, instead of flying directly from Culver City to Tonopah.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit