Supreme Court of Iowa June 11, 1968, 52950 (McCuen v. Hartsock)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-1968

SNELL, Justice.

This is an action in equity brought in two counts by plaintiff appellant as a beneficiary of a joint, mutual and contractual will executed by Sadie and Amos S. Hart-sock, her parents. Count I alleges that certain inter vivos transfers were made in violation of the provisions of the will. Count II asks that the money transferred be subject, to a constructive trust in favor of the plaintiff. The trial court found insufficient evidence to declare a constructive trust, but found the transfers unreasonable and ordered $10,000 (½) of the money returned to the estate of the deceased and be divided under the terms of the will. As noted, infra, this would give plaintiff one-fourth of the amount involved. From the premise of fairness this might appeal to us as a Solomon-like treatment but it does not authorize us to substitute our opinion for what her father actually did with his own money.

Amos and Sadie Hartsock were husband and wife, they owned land and farmed in Pocahontas County. Amos owned 134 acres and Sadie owned 120 acres. They had two children, Donna and Harlan, who are the plaintiff and the defendant in this action. At the time of Amos’ death, Harlan was 52 and Donna was 37.

After finishing high school, Harlan stayed with his parents on the farm until he was 26. He left for six or seven years and then returned to assist his parents on the farm in 1943 or 1944. Harlan and Amos farmed together until Amos retired in 1957 when Harlan bought Amos’ machinery and continued to farm 134 acres of the land as a tenant. The evidence does not show the net worth of Amos and Sadie at that time but it does indicate that Harlan’s efforts were helpful.

Donna graduated in 1946, attended college for two years, was married and since then has lived away from the Laurens community. At the time of Amos’ death Donna was living in Des Moines.

Amos and Sadie accumulated savings. Eventually they established joint tenancy savings accounts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.