Court of Appeals of Georgia December 5, 1968, 43783, 43784 (Malone v. Ottinger)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1968

Whitman, Judge.

The motions by both plaintiffs to dismiss the appeals for failure of the defendants to file transcripts within the prescribed time are without merit. No court reporter’s transcript was involved in either case. The depositions, affidavits, etc., necessary for the motions for summary judgment and necessary for the appeals were on file with the clerk of the trial court and a part of the record before the notices of appeal were filed. The delay in transmitting the record to this court was certified by the deputy clerk of the trial court as “due to the stress of work in this office and is no way the fault of either party.”

The facts of the present case are similar to those in the case of

Malcom v. Malcolm,

112 Ga. App. 151 (144 SE2d 188), wherein the grant of a summary judgment for the plaintiff on the issue of liability was held to be erroneous and was reversed. However, in that case there was evidence that the plaintiff, the lead car, stopped so suddenly that the defendant in the following car could not avoid the collision. In the present case the defendant has testified only that she did not know the car ahead of her had stopped. While the party opposing a motion for summary judgment is entitled to a liberal construction in his favor of the pleadings and evidence

(McCarty v. National Life &c. Ins. Co.,

107 Ga. App. 178 (129 SE2d 408)), the defendant’s testimony that she did not know the plaintiffs’ car had stopped can not be construed to mean that the plaintiffs’ car stopped suddenly.

The case is controlled by

Sutherland’s Eggs, Inc. v. Barber,

116 Ga. App. 393 (157 SE2d 491), wherein it was held: “Where the evidence showed the plaintiff to be completely free of negligence and the defendant’s testimony revealed no legal reason

*782

or excuse for his failure to stop the vehicle he was driving prior to colliding with the rear of the plaintiff’s automobile, the trial judge did not err in directing a verdict for the plaintiff on the question of liability.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.