Hawaii Supreme Court September 30, 1968, 4687 (Hung Wo Ching v. Hawaiian Restaurants, Ltd.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-09-1968

*564

OPINION OF THE COURT BY

ABE, J.

The plaintiffs, as lessors, and the defendant, as lessee, executed a lease of a parcel of land at the intersection of Kalakaua Avenue and Kapiolani Boulevard in Honolulu. The defendant operates a restaurant under the name of Coco’s on the premises.

The lease is for a term commencing July 1, 1960 and ending June 30, 1985 and provides for a monthly rental of $2,250 for the period ending June 30, 1965. The lease contains a rental provision calling for renewal negotiation every five years throughout the twenty-five year term. It also provides that when the parties are unable to agree on the rental for any five-year period, the annual rental shall be 6 percent of the fair market value as determined by “three impartial appraisers.”

1

The parties were unable to agree on the rental for the second five-year period and each party appointed an appraiser. When the two appraisers could not agree on the fair market value for

*565

the determination of the rental, plaintiffs brought suit for a declaratory judgment in the first circuit court for the interpretation of the words “fair market value.”

The defendant moved to require arbitration of this dispute over the rent and to stay the suit, contending that the lease required arbitration. The trial judge denied this motion and also refused to allow the defendant to take an interlocutory appeal on this point.

After trial, the trial court ruled that the words “fair market value” of the demised land as used in the lease meant fair market value of the land at its highest and best use, unencumbered by the lease. The defendant appealed from this judgment.

The covenant of the lease provided for the appointment of three “appraisers” only when the lessors and lessee were unable to agree on the rental.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.