Supreme Court of South Carolina April 30, 1968, 18785 (McCullough v. Gatch)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-04-1968
Brailsford, Justice.
After dark on April 14, 1964, on Farrow Road, in Rich-land County, an automobile belonging to Forrest Blackwell and operated by John McCullough was in collision with one of two unattended cows on the highway. Palmetto State Hospital, a facility of the State of South Carolina under the jurisdiction of the South Carolina Mental Health Commission, operates a nearby farm, from which the cows had strayed. Charles Gatch was employed as supervisor of this farm.
McCullough and Blackwell, respectively, sued Gatch for damages for personal injury and property damage. The cases were tried together in the Richland County Court and resulted in verdicts for the plaintiffs. In this consolidated appeal Gatch urges that the court erred in refusing his motion for verdicts by direction of the Court. Other grounds of appeal are urged, which, in our view of the case, need not be considered.
Plaintiffs offered no evidence except as to the immediate circumstances of the collision and its consequences. Gatch was connected with the incident only by the admissions of his answers that he was employed as farm supervisor by Palmetto State Hospital and, inferentially, that the cows in question came from that farm. Gatch, offering no testimony, moved for a directed verdict at the conclusion of plaintiff’s evidence.
The trial court recognized that there was no evidence that Gatch had been guilty of any negligent act or omission, but held that the unexplained presence of the cows on the highway raised an issue for the jury as to whether he had violated Section 6-311, Code of 1962. The court instructed the jury that any violation of this statute, which we quote below, would be negligence
per
se:
*174
“It shall be unlawful for the owner or manager of any domestic animal of any description
wilfully or negligently to permit
any such animal to run at large beyond the limits of his own land or the lands leased, occupied or controlled by him.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit