Supreme Court of Pennsylvania October 3, 1968, Appeal, 309 (Philadelphia v. Mancini)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-10-1968

Opinion by

Mr. Justice Jones,

Amil Mancini was a cement contractor in Philadelphia whose business generally entailed working for general construction contractors for which work Mancini would submit bids to the general contractors. Mancini’s business required the employment of other persons, both residents and nonresidents of Philadelphia.

The City of Philadelphia (City), by ordinance, imposes a tax on all salaries, wages and other compensation earned by residents of the City or by nonresidents whose work is done or services performed within the

*358

City.

1

Under tlie provisions of this ordinance each employer, “who employs one or more persons on a salary, wage, commission or other compensation basis”

must

deduct the tax, make a return and pay the tax every three months.

2

Mancini for 1957 did file the requisite wage tax forms but for 1958, 1959 and 1960 did not file any returns or pay any taxes under the ordinance. After an examination of Maneini’s records, although the City levied assessments for the years in question against Mancini,

3

he has never paid any of the taxes allegedly due the City.

The examination of Mancini’s records revealed that, during the three years in question, Mancini neither withheld nor deducted any wage taxes from the wages due to his employees.

Mancini’s position is that, during this three year period, the general contractors for whom he worked paid him only the

net

amount of wages due his employees, i.e., that amount which, after deduction of the wage tax, was due his employees, and the amount of the wage tax due on his employees’ wages was withheld from him by the general contractors and never paid to or received by him.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.