Wisconsin Supreme Court June 4, 1968, 254 (Kenosha Teachers Union Local 557 v. Wisconsin Employment Relations Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-06-1968
Connor T. Hansen, J.
This appeal presents two issues:
(1) Whether the trial court erred in not determining as a matter of law that one motivating factor in the nonrenewal of Spaight’s contract was his involvement in union activities.
(2) Whether there is substantial evidence, in view of the record as a whole, to support the determination of the WERC that nonrenewal of Spaight’s contract was not motivated by his union activities.
(1) We have carefully reviewed the entire record in this proceeding and conclude that in this particular case the question of whether union activity was a motivating factor in the nonrenewal of the teaching contract was a question of fact and not one of law.
Appellants contend that the fourth reason enumerated by Hosmanek in support of his recommendation relates to a brief, but heated discussion which occurred between
*202
the librarian and Spaight in the professional library. It is uncontroverted that the topic of discussion was unionism and teaching professionalism. It is also undisputed that the librarian reported the incident to Hosmanek who later mentioned this to Spaight as an example of the latter’s unprofessional attitude. However, the undisputed occurrence of the incident does not, in and of itself, constitute a motivating factor as a matter of law. The incident must be viewed within the scope of the relationship between Hosmanek and Spaight. Spaight was not exceptionally active in the union. He was neither an organizer, nor an officer, agent or steward. Hosmanek testified that at the time he began evaluating Spaight he had no knowledge of Spaight’s participation in either the KTU or the Kenosha Education Association (KEA). He also testified that when he composed the teacher evaluation during Spaight’s second year, the only indication Hosmanek had of Spaight’s relation to the KTU was the librarian’s complaint relating to the library incident.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit