Supreme Court of Iowa April 9, 1968, 52883 (Brooks v. Dickey)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-1968

MOORE, Justice.

This is a law action tried to the court for damages to automobiles resulting from collision on a narrow bridge. Plaintiff Harold Brooks appeals from denial of his claim and judgment for defendant Donald Dickey on his counterclaim. We affirm.

About 9:30 a.m. March 7, 1966, plaintiff was driving his 1962 Ford in a southerly direction on County Road W in Muscatine County. Located thereon approximately 10 miles west of Muscatine is a bridge 300 feet long, 15½ feet wide, commonly known as Salisbury Bridge. We take judicial notice this is a relatively narrow bridge by modern standards. In any event, several witnesses so described it. The approach to the bridge from the west curves over a distance of approximately 300 feet resulting in a ninety degree directional change so that the road actually runs east and west across the bridge.

Defendant’s wife, accompanied by two of her minor children, was then driving defendant’s 1964 Oldsmobile in a westerly direction across the bridge. A Collision of the left front corners of the two vehicles occurred about six feet east of the west end of the bridge. On trial the parties stipulated the amount of damages to each vehicle.

Each driver had traveled the road on several prior occasions and was familiar with the width and flow of traffic across the bridge. .

Plaintiff testified he saw defendant’s car midway on the bridge as he was negotiating the curve leading to it from the west. Defendant’s wife observed plaintiff’s vehicle about the same time. Both estimated their respective speeds as IS to 20 miles per hour when each first saw the other.

Plaintiff fúrther testified that upon seeing defendant’s car he began decelerating on the somewhat slick gravel road and eventually came to a complete stop with the front eight feet of his car on the bridge and the rear remaining on the gravel road. His vehicle was stopped within three inches from the south guardrail of the bridge.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.