Michigan Supreme Court June 10, 1968, Calendar No 13, Docket 51,743 (Kwaiser v. Peters)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-06-1968

Souris, J.

(for reversal and

remand). We granted leave to appeal for the limited purpose of determining whether the trial court erred in denying plaintiff’s motion for new trial based upon allegations that a juror improperly associated with defendant and his counsel immediately after verdict favorable to defendant and that the same juror falsely answered his personal history questionnaire required by GCR 1963, 510. 379 Mich 765. The Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court. 6 Mich App 153.

At an evidentiary hearing on plaintiff’s motion for new trial, witnesses testified that within about an hour after return of the jury’s verdict, the defendant tavern owner and one of the jurors entered the defendant’s tavern, where they were joined soon thereafter by defendant’s trial counsel and several members of counsel’s law firm. At least some of the group, including the juror] were served beverages. None of the witnesses heard any of the conversation of the group of which the juror was a part.

The juror, the defendant, and the defendant’s lawyers were not called by plaintiff to testify at the hearing on his motion, nor did they testify voluntarily. No other proofs were offered from which it could be found that the juror was known by the defendant or his attorneys before the trial or that, they had com

*76

lmmicated about the caso privately before or during the trial. In short, this record is barren of any evidence that the plaintiff was prejudiced by the conduct of defendant, his attorneys, and the juror. The question becomes whether, absent a showing of prejudice, a new trial should have been granted because defendant and his attorneys fraternized with a juror immediately after a verdict was rendered favorable to defendant.

Just recently, in

People

v.

Schram

(1966), 378 Mich 145, where the assistant prosecutor, during the trial of a criminal case, conversed with two jurors, a majority of this Court refused relief to the defendant absent a showing of prejudice to him.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.