Wisconsin Supreme Court May 7, 1968 (Tews Lime & Cement Co. v. Department of Industry, Labor & Human Relations)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-05-1968

Beilfuss, J.

From the briefs and arguments of counsel four issues are presented:

1. Was the heart attack suffered by the deceased, Eugene Louis Miller, an accidental injury compensable under the Workmen’s Compensation Act, ch. 102, Stats., 1963?

2. Was Miller’s act of returning to work a refusal to follow medical treatment within the meaning of sec. 102.42 (7), Stats.?

3. Should the award be set aside as being the result of a constructive fraud upon the employer?

4. Was the commission required to make a finding concerning Miller’s alleged refusal to follow medical advice?

The first issue is whether the fatal heart attack suffered by Eugene Miller was an accidental injury subject to workmen’s compensation benefits.

The commission’s finding that Miller’s death was caused by the work effort of June 9, 1964, is wholly supported by the medical testimony. Dr. Flood testified he was of the opinion the work Miller was doing aggravated the preexisting condition and precipitated the heart attack. Dr. L. W. Sennett, a specialist in internal medicine and cardiology, who examined Miller’s medical records, concluded there was a causal relationship between the deceased’s heart attack and the work exertion. A report of Dr. Nathan Grossman, which was made a part of the record, also concluded there was a causal relationship between the work effort and Miller’s death.

From the medical evidence offered at the hearing, it is clear that the physical exertion by the deceased in his employment was an immediate cause of the heart attack. The question is whether it is compensable as an “accident or disease causing injury [which] arises out

*671

of his employment” within the meaning of the Workmen’s Compensation Act.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.