Michigan Court of Appeals March 21, 1968, Docket 2,465 (Haggerty v. MacGregor)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-03-1968

J. H. G-illis, P. J.

Plaintiff James J. Haggerty sued defendant Norman R. MacGregor on a promissory note executed in October, 1950. After a non-jury trial, the circuit judge made written findings and on July 1, 1966, entered a judgment of no cause of action. This appeal is taken from that judgment.

In 1950, defendant and Leo Bonnie proposed to open and operate an automobile dealership in Lake City, Alichigan. Bonnie approached plaintiff for the purpose of securing needed capital. In return for a loan of $8,000 Bonnie and the defendant jointly executed a two-year note in favor of plaintiff which formed the basis of this suit. The business venture

*673

encountered financial difficulties and in 1952 Bonnie purchased defendant’s interest and recorded a bulk sale affidavit. Bonnie agreed to assume all the business debts.

Shortly thereafter, defendant moved to California and after a series of business reverses in that State he was adjudicated a bankrupt and received a discharge in October 1954. The 1950 note to Haggerty was not listed in the schedule of indebtedness filed in conjunction with the bankruptcy proceedings.

Defendant returned to Michigan, and for substantial periods between 1954 and 1962 was outside the United States on business for his employer, Ford Motor Company. The evidence discloses that during this period Haggerty knew of MacGregor’s whereabouts and occasionally encountered MacGregor but at no time was reference made to the note.

Bonnie signed a note for $9,440 dated April 22, 1954 (Thursday), payable to plaintiff, which represented the original 1950 note plus the interest accrued to the date of the 1954 note. Bonnie made no payments on the original loan until the same week that the 1954 note was executed. Plaintiff did not surrender the original note. After periodic payments had been made by Bonnie, plaintiff stamped the 1954 note “paid in full” and wrote across the face of the note “Settled in full as far as Bonnie is concerned for $4,000.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.