Michigan Court of Appeals December 23, 1968, Docket 1,865 1,866 (Martel v. Duffy-Mott Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-12-1968

Levin, P. J.

The plaintiffs appeal a directed verdict granted at the conclusion of their proofs. The complaint charged the defendant, Duffy-Mott Corporation, with both negligence and breach of implied warranty of merchantability. On appeal the plain

*69

tiffs rely solely on the statutory implied warranty that to be merchantable goods must be fit for the ordinary purposes for which they are used. MCLA, § 440.2314(2) (c) (Stat Ann 1964 Rev § 19.2314[2] [c]).

Edwina Martel served her sons, Brian, 8, and Gary, 10, Mott’s applesauce as part of their meal. Brian mixed his applesauce with the rest of his food and consumed a sizeable po.rtion of the mixture. Gary ate the applesauce separately and after a spoonful or 2 reported to his mother that the applesauce tasted funny. She tasted and smelled the applesauce — at the trial she and Gary testified that it both tasted and smelled bad — and immediately telephoned the poison control center at Children’s Hospital which, on the basis-, of her description of the applesauce, instructed her to take the children and remaining applesauce to the nearest hospital. When she arrived the applesauce was examined by hospital personnel who decided to and did pump the children’s stomachs. Mrs. MJartel was advised to watch the children carefully_ that night for certain symptoms. These symptoms. did not appear and no other ill effects were suffered.'

There was testimony the children were apprehensive on the way to the hospital although neither Mrs. Martel nor her sons knew of the imminent stomach pumping until after they reached the hospital. Mrs. Martel conceded the children may have gagged because of excitement or fright and not necessarily because of a deleterious substance in the applesauce. On the way to the hospital the hoys said they were having a hard time breathing and asked to open the windows. Later they were chilled and asked that the windows he closed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.