Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) June 14, 1968 (George v. Standard Slag Company)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-06-1968
PALMORE, Judge.
A jury returned its verdict in favor of the owners of 25 residential properties in Ashland against Standard Slag Company, Inc., for damages attributed to air pollution emanating from Standard’s nearby slag plant. The owners appeal from a judgment n. o. v. for the defendant company. The judgment conditionally directs a new trial in event of a reversal. CR 50.03. It is our conclusion that a new trial should be had, principally because the verdict on its face, when construed in the light of the evidence, appears to be inconsistent with the instructions and thus contrary to law.
As the alleged nuisance is permanent in nature, the correct measure of damages is the resulting diminution in market value of the respective pieces of property,
1
and the jury was clearly instructed to that effect, with the additional caveat that “in arriving at this- result you will not award any damages for (a) Air pollution by dust, odors or noise which ordinarily, normally and reasonably would be expected from industry, including defendant’s business, or the area, or (b) For personal discomfort, annoyance or sickness to plaintiffs, or either of them, this action being only an action for diminution of the market value of the plaintiffs’ property as measured by these instructions and the evidence of discomfort, annoyance or sickness of plaintiffs * * * goes to you only for- the purpose and you can consider it only for the purpose of considering whether and to what extent the property of plaintiffs * * * has been depreciated in market value, if any,” etc.
2
Two forms of verdict were submitted to the jury with the instructions, one finding for the defendant and the other for
*713
the plaintiffs. The one finding for the plaintiffs listed the 25 pieces of property individually and called for a “before value,” an “after value,” and a “difference” for each.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit