Supreme Court of Pennsylvania January 9, 1968, Appeal, 343 (Perez v. Blumenthal Bros. Choc. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1968

Opinion by

Mr. Justice O’Brien,

Appellee commenced an action of trespass against appellant, his employer, alleging that appellant had violated its duty to protect the health and safety of appellee, its employee. Specifically, appellee alleged that he was exposed to heavy dust produced in a grinding operation, and that this, together with injurious fumes caused by the high temperatures associated with appellant’s operation, caused him an aggravation of a latent tubercular condition and a preexisting pulmonary emphysema and severe bronchitis.

The case was heard in a nonjury trial resulting in a verdict for appellee. The trial judge found that appellee’s condition was caused or aggravated by a con

*227

tinued exposure to a heavy concentration of dust and excessive heat in his employment with appellant. Appellant’s exceptions to the findings and verdict of the trial judge were heard and dismissed. This appeal followed the entry of judgment on the verdict of the trial judge.

Appellant asserts in this appeal that appellee’s action is barred by The Pennsylvania Occupational Disease Act,

1

and that the finding of the trial judge that appellee’s emphysema was caused by any condition existing in appellant’s plant was not supported by competent medical evidence. We disagree with appellant on both counts.

One is tempted to dismiss appellant’s argument relative to The Pennsylvania Occupational Disease Act out of hand, inasmuch as appellee, prior to the filing of the instant action of trespass had filed a claim under the Act, which claim was resisted by appellant on the ground that emphysema is not an occupational disease. Appellant ought not to be permitted to have it both ways. Be that as it may, however, the Act itself makes clear that it is not a bar to the trespass action. The Act enumerates occupational diseases in §108, 77 P.S. §1208.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.