Supreme Court of Rhode Island June 19, 1968, 140-M.P (Warner v. BD. OF REVIEW OF NEWPORT)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-06-1968

243 A.2d 92 (1968) Elmer WARNER et ux. v. BOARD OF REVIEW OF the CITY OF NEWPORT. Nos. 140-M.P. Supreme Court of Rhode Island. June 19, 1968. *93 Macioci and Morrison, for petitioners. James S. O'Brien, City Sol., Moore, Virgadamo, Boyle & Lynch, Newport, Francis J. Boyle, Newport, of counsel, amicus curiae, for respondent. OPINION ROBERTS, Chief Justice. This petition for certiorari was brought to review the respondent zoning board's dismissal of the petitioners' application for a special exception permitting them to erect three connecting apartment buildings on land located in an R-40 district. The writ issued, and pursuant thereto the records in the case have been certified to this court. It appears therefrom that the property under consideration, containing about 4½ acres, is located on the west side of Chastellux Avenue, Newport, and is designated as lot 3 on assessor's plat 42. The record discloses that these petitioners in 1952 had applied for and been granted an exception to convert to apartment use a large frame dwelling house then occupying the tract, specifically authorizing two apartments each on the first and third floors and seven separate rooms for rental on the second floor. Now they seek permission by way of a special exception for the erection on the tract of three connecting buildings, each of which is to contain 11 apartment units. Several remonstrants filed motions to dismiss the application for various reasons and submitted memoranda of law supporting these reasons. On April 24, 1967, the respondent board dismissed the application "* * * on the ground that it would be *94 the granting of an exception on an exception, which is prohibited by a previous decision rendered by the Supreme Court in the Bernstein case." Thus, in holding that it was without authority to grant the instant exception, the board relied upon the decision of this court in Bernstein v. Zoning Board of Review, 99 R.I. 494, 209 A.2d 52.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.