Supreme Court of Vermont June 4, 1968, 1909 (Heath v. Orlandi)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-06-1968

Holden, C.J.

This action arose from a motor vehicle collision on the Nelson Pond Road in South Woodbury, Vermont, August 28, 1965. The plaintiff was proceeding easterly in a Pontiac sedan with a boat and trailer attached. He approached a moderate curve to his right on a down grade. He was traveling at a speed of twenty-five to thirty miles per hour. To his right, on the south side of the road, was a drainage ditch at the base of an abrupt rock ledge. As he entered the bend in the highway a Chevrolet flatbed track, traveling in the opposite direction, was leaving the curve. The truck was owned by the defendant Orlandi and operated by the defendant Hatch. According to the plaintiff’s estimate, the truck first came into his view when the vehicles were thirty to fifty feet apart. At this distance the plaintiff applied his brakes and the operator of the track veered diagonally to his right. Before the plaintiff’s car could be brought to a halt, his left front fender collided at the left rear wheel of the truck.

According to the plaintiff’s evidence, when the defendant’s truck first came into view it was in the center of the highway with its left front wheel occupying a portion of the plaintiff’s lane of travel. The state police officer, who investigated the accident, testified that the jamming of the plaintiff’s left front fender against the tire practically immobilized the plaintiff’s vehicle on impact. By reference to broken glass and dirt found in the highway, the investigating officer located the point of impact in the plaintiff’s lane of travel seven feet from the south line of the highway. The road at this point was approximately sixteen feet wide.

When the plaintiff rested his case the defendants’ motion for a directed verdict was granted. In granting the defendants’ motion, the

*206

district court ruled these facts insufficient as a matter of law, to establish actionable negligence on the part of the defendants. The plaintiff appeals.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.