Michigan Court of Appeals July 26, 1968, Docket 2,866 (Hull v. Detroit Equipment Installation, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-07-1968
J. H. Gtllis, J.
Defendant-lessee appeals the granting of a summary judgment to plaintiff-lessor. The litigation centered on the liability for the increased sewage charges occasioned by defendant’s use of the leased premises as a laundromat and dry cleaning establishment.
The trial court correctly held that the interpretation of the lease agreement was a question of law properly resolved on a motion for summary judgment. At a hearing on the motion brought pursuant to G-CB 1963,117.2(3) both parties asserted the lack
*534
of any material issue of fact on the lease agreement. In fact, defendant-lessee’s counsel advised the court, “There is absolutely no factual question involved.” While each of the parties assert that there is no factual dispute, this does not of necessity give the trial court
carte blanche
authority to resolve ultimate factual issues on the motion. The court’s role is to determine from the pleadings, affidavits and other evidence on the record whether there are genuine issues of fact. See
Zamler
v.
Smith
(1965), 375 Mich 675.
When a lease is unambiguous in its terms, what the parties intended by the language employed in the lease is a matter of law for the court’s determination and not a question for the consideration of the fact finder. See
Brown
v.
Schiappacasse
(1897), 115 Mich 47. Although the parties here refer to other provisions of the lease as implying who is to pay the sewage charge, it is hardly disputable that the lease was silent as to this provision and the trial court was correct in so ruling.
The narrow issue presented for our determination is: In the absence of any specific provision in a lease, who is to pay for added sewage charges occasioned by the lessee’s use of the premises?
In
Wycoff
v.
Gavriloff Motors, Inc.
(1961), 362 Mich 582 (86 ALR2d 663), the Court was called upon to decide an issue similar to that now before us.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit