Appellate Court of Illinois March 11, 1968, Gen. 51,143 (People v. Thomas)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-03-1968

MR. JUSTICE ADESKO

delivered the opinion of the court.

Wendell Thomas was indicted for the murder of Ernest Winters. The jury found the defendant guilty and fixed his punishment at imprisonment in the penitentiary for the term of thirty-three years. He prosecutes this appeal alleging the following errors:

(1) The evidence shows that the offense committed, if any, was manslaughter and not murder;

(2) The State’s attorney prejudiced the jury by improper and inflammatory argument; and

(3) The sentence of thirty-three years is excessive.

Beginning in the afternoon of August 27, 1958, Ernest Winters, Frank Sims and defendant were out drinking together. At about 8:00 p. m., Barbara Davis joined the group. Winters, Davis and defendant then drove to Winters’ house to pick up his wife Ernestine. Upon arriving there, Winters took offense to his wife referring to another man as “baby.” He slapped her across the face and she slapped him back. The Winters got back into the car with Davis and defendant and started driving around.

During the ride, the Winters began arguing again. Winters stopped the car near a vacant lot and jumped out. He picked up a stick and started chasing his wife, who had also gotten out of the car. Defendant intervened and tried to stop the Winters from fighting. Ernestine ran off down the street while the two men started pushing each other. After wrestling with Winters for a few moments, defendant ran off down the alley.

Winters and Davis started to get back into the car when defendant reappeared. He told Winters, “I am going to get my gun,” and also to wait for him at 42nd and Drexel. Davis convinced Winters to drive away and find Sims.

Davis and Winters drove to Sims’ home at 814 East 42nd Street, about 1 block from the vacant lot. Sims came outside and was talking with Winters for about 10 or 15 minutes when defendant emerged from an alley just up the block.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.