Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court December 24, 1968 (Vance v. Gould)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-12-1968

Kirk, J.

In this action of tort for personal injuries allegedly caused by the negligent operation of the defendant’s supermarket where the plaintiff, a business invitee, tripped on an empty carton, the jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff. The single question is whether the evidence was sufficient to submit the case to the jury.

We review the case in light of the settled principles stated by Qua, J. in

Duff

v.

Webster,

315 Mass. 102, 103, and in

Kelly

v.

Railway Exp. Agency, Inc.

315 Mass. 301, 302.

The duty owed by a storekeeper to a customer on the premises is so familiar as not to require repetition.

Parker

v.

Jordan Marsh Co.

310 Mass. 227, 229.

Coates

v.

First Natl. Stores Inc.

322 Mass. 563, 565. Numerous cases applying the rule are collected and classified in

Letiecq

v.

Denholm & McKay Co.

328 Mass. 120, 121-122, where we recognized that “[WJhether a case falls on one side of the line or the other is often difficult and some of the cases cited . . . [in the opinion J are so close that opinions may well differ.” We do not attempt to make a comparative analysis of the several cases cited by the parties. In some respects on their facts the cited cases resemble, in others they differ from the case at bar. The rule is constant. The facts, which usually must be established by the trier of fact on conflicting evidence, vary with each case. The result of each case must rest on its facts.

We state the evidence in light most favorable to the plaintiff. The plaintiff had been a customer of the defendant for many years and was familiar with the store and its routine operations. On October 11, 1962, she was in

*106

jured while shopping in an alcove located within and at the front of the store. The overall dimensions of the alcove were thirteen feet wide and seven and. one-half feet deep. There were shelves on three sides of the alcove. The open side faced an aisle.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.