Appellate Court of Illinois June 19, 1968, Gen. 10,921 (Still v. Still)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-06-1968
TRAPP, J.
The plaintiff, Riley Still, appeals from a decree which denied his complaint for divorce alleging desertion, and which granted a divorce upon his wife’s counterclaim alleging cruelty and adultery. The decree awarded alimony in gross in the sum of $10,000 to be paid in semiannual installments of $1,000.
Neither pleadings nor decree are contained in the abstract, or additional abstract presented, and it appears that only portions of the testimony are included. As a result the issues are difficult of precise definition.
Plaintiff urges error in the determination by the court of the claims of the parties concerning the alleged cruelty charged in the counterclaim, and the denial of divorce upon the allegations of desertion. Upon the first point, the testimony of the wife is corroborated by the testimony of the two children of the parties. As to the latter point, the only testimony is that of plaintiff and his wife. Plaintiff argues that his testimony is unimpeached. While technically true, such testimony is, however, contradicted by other witnesses upon the facts at issue. Here the trial judge observed the witnesses in their respective manners in testifying. It is axiomatic that he has the superior means to measure credibility. The appeal presented does not persuade that his findings were contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence.
It is urged that the trail court erred in denying plaintiff’s defense of condonation to the alleged acts of cruelty. To speak precisely, there is no such defense presented in the abstract. There is a fragment of testimony by plaintiff which might constitute a claim of acts of condonation, but such were denied by the wife. The trial court commented upon such testimony in the light of the circumstances in evidence, and again, he made a determination of credibility. He also considered the testimony in the light of conduct which would revive the original grounds of the wife for relief.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit