Supreme Court of Vermont August 9, 1968, 1931 (In Re Calhoun)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-08-1968
Per Curiam.
So that there may be no uncertainty, it should be understood that this Court holds the offense of failing to file income tax returns to be professional misconduct. Although it may not necessarily require disbarment, it is a proper basis for disciplinary action.
In re McShane,
122 Vt. 442, 175 A.2d 508. It is not only a failure to perform a duty imposed by law on income-earning citizens generally, it is a breach of responsibility that tends to discredit the legal profession which the respondent, as a member of the bar, is obligated to uphold with strict fidelity. See annotation, 59 A.L.R.2d 1398, 1405.
This is such a case. During the hearing held before the three-man committee of the bar appointed by this Court to investigate the matter, and in their findings, some doubt appeared as to the significance of the
McShane
case. Since, in that case, this Court administered
*221
a penalty by way of reprimand, it should be clear that misconduct was found, otherwise there would be no foundation for the punishment. When misconduct is established, this Court is not confined to the remedy of disbarment, but may adjust the penalty to what it finds to be the measure of culpability of the attorney, in accordance with its jurisdiction over attorneys as officers of this Court.
In re Paddock,
114 Vt. 207, 210, 42 A.2d 342.
Thus, when in
In re McShane, supra,
122 Vt. 442, 443, 175 A.2d 508, reference was made to the lack of bad faith or evil intent, it was in connection with the matter of mitigation, not the issue of guilt or innocence. As the opinion shows, significance was also given to the frustration of the attorney’s efforts to complete his returns by the confiscation of his only records. This was reflected in his plea to the Federal charge, the penalty there assessed, the findings of the bar committee and disposition here.
These considerations were felt sufficient to distinguish that penalty from the one involved in
Ford’s Case,
102 N.H. 24, 149 A.2d 863.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit