Wisconsin Supreme Court February 27, 1968 (Green v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-02-1968
Heffernan, J.
It is the contention of the defendant that, although there was no request for a manslaughter instruction, it was error to fail to submit such an instruction to the jury if the state of the evidence would have made such a submission proper. It is his contention that the court must submit the manslaughter instruction unless the defendant, as well as his counsel, waives the manslaughter instruction. Whether manslaughter could properly have been submitted we need not decide, and for the purpose of this appeal we assume that the question might properly have been given to the jury at the request of either the defense or prosecution.
We have heretofore concluded that when a defendant requests a manslaughter instruction and there is reasonable ground for such an instruction to be found in the evidence, it would be reversible error not to give it.
Zenou v. State
(1958), 4 Wis. 2d 655, 668, 91 N. W. 2d 208. We, however, held in
Neuenfeldt v. State
(1965), 29 Wis. 2d 20, 138 N. W. 2d 252, that no duty devolves upon the trial judge to submit a lesser degree of homicide in the absence of a request. We stated therein, at page 31, citing cases:
“. . . unless a request is made for an instruction of the lesser included offense it is not error for the trial
*364
court not to give the instruction on its own motion even though the evidence would sustain it.”
The
Neuenfeldt Case
discussed
in extenso
the rationale of the rule that is accepted in Wisconsin. In
Williamson v. State
(1966), 31 Wis. 2d 677, 683, 143 N. W. 2d 486, we stated:
“Mr. Williamson further urges that the failure of the trial court to have submitted a verdict bn manslaughter was a prejudicial error. When there is a reasonable basis to believe that the evidence will sustain a lesser included offense, it should be submitted by the trial court.
Weston v. State
(1965), 28 Wis. (2d) 136, 142, 143, 135 N. W. (2d) 820.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit