Wisconsin Supreme Court February 27, 1968 (Burke v. Poeschl Brothers, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-02-1968
*230
BeilfüSS, J.
The issues on the appeal are:
1. Was the defendant-appellant, Poeschl Brothers, Inc., causally negligent?
2. Was the plaintiff-respondent, Frank A. Burke, con-tributorily negligent as a matter of law?
3. Is the jury’s award for past and future pain, suffering and disability excessive?
The defendant-contractor’s duty to the plaintiff in the present case is prescribed by two legislative provisions:
(a) Sec. 62.15(11) of the Wisconsin Statutes:
“Street Obstruction. All contractors doing any work which shall in any manner obstruct the streets or sidewalks shall put up and maintain barriers and lights to prevent accidents, and be liable for all damages caused by failure so to do. All contracts shall contain a provision covering this liability,
1
and also a provision making the contractor liable for all damages caused by the negligent digging up of streets, alleys or public grounds, or which may result from his carelessness in the prosecution of such work.”
(b) Sec. 29 of ch. 5 of the city of Milwaukee Ordinance :
“Any person installing, excavating, constructing, reconstructing, grading, filling, or doing any other repairing or improving in any public way or public place shall provide adequate barricade lights and such other protective devices as may be necessary to adequately warn the public of the condition of the area and prevent injury to any person or property.”
The statute and the ordinance are safety measures. This court has firmly established the principle that the violation of a safety statute or ordinance constitutes negligence per se.
Kalkopf v. Donald Sales & Mfg. Co.
(1967), 33 Wis. 2d 247, 147 N. W. 2d 277;
Szafranski v. Radetsky
(1966), 31 Wis. 2d 119, 141 N. W. 2d 902;
Meihost v. Meihost
(1966), 29 Wis. 2d 537, 139 N. W. 2d 116.
*231
The appellant does not argue that the failure to erect barricades was not negligence but earnestly contends the lack of barricades was not a cause of the plaintiff’s fall and injuries.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit