Supreme Court of Pennsylvania November 12, 1968, Appeals, 139 and 140 (Commonwealth v. Christman)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-11-1968

Opinion by

Mb. Justice Robebts,

In 1951 appellant was convicted of mnrder in the first degree and was sentenced to life imprisonment. No appeal was taken. In 1967 appellant filed a writ of habeas corpus, claiming (1) that he had not been represented by counsel at the time of his sentencing; (2) that he had not had a separate hearing to determine the validity of his allegedly involuntary confession; (3) that the trial judge had denied appellant his right to counsel by directing him to remain silent while a witness was being cross-examined; and (4) that appellant did not know his right to appeal, nor of his right to have counsel appointed to perfect an appeal as required by

Douglas v. California,

372 U.S. 353, 83 S. Ct. 814 (1963);

Commonwealth v. Wilson,

430 Pa. 1, 241 A. 2d 760 (1968).

A hearing was held on appellant’s petition, after which Judge Ellenbogen concluded that appellant had not been represented by counsel at sentencing. Accordingly, appellant’s sentence was vacated and Judge Ellenbogen, later sitting as sentencing judge, reimposed a life sentence on appellant, who then of course was represented by counsel. Appellant was also given a hearing under

Jackson v. Denno,

378 U.S. 368, 84 S. Ct. 1774 (1964), to determine the validity of his con

*458

fession; this issue, as well as appellant’s claim that he had been denied the right to counsel at trial, was determined adversely to appellant. The hearing judge did not decide appellant’s denial of the right to appeal claim because he felt that his determination that appellant “is entitled to be resentenced, with counsel present, will automatically afford him the right to file an appeal within the prescribed time limits . . . .” Appellant has appealed from the resentencing and from the determinations made at his collateral hearing.

Reimposition of Sentence

Appellant apparently has appealed from the reimposition of a life sentence, but it is unclear on what his claim is based.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.