Superior Court of Pennsylvania April 5, 1968, Appeal, 68 (Commonwealth v. Hoffman)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-04-1968
combined-opinion
212 Pa. Superior Ct. 206 (1968) Commonwealth v. Hoffman, Appellant. Superior Court of Pennsylvania. Submitted March 11, 1968. April 5, 1968. Before WRIGHT, P.J., WATKINS, MONTGOMERY, JACOBS, HOFFMAN, SPAULDING, and HANNUM, JJ. Richard U.T. Hoffman, appellant, in propria persona. Jerome T. Foerster, Assistant District Attorney, LeRoy S. Zimmerman, District Attorney, for Commonwealth, appellee. OPINION PER CURIAM, April 5, 1968: Order affirmed. DISSENTING OPINION BY SPAULDING, J.: In addition to several contentions regarding the merits, petitioner alleges that he is entitled to counsel to aid him in prosecuting this appeal from the dismissal without hearing of his Post Conviction Hearing *207 Act petition[1] by the court below. This court today dismisses that contention. I disagree. In my judgment such a guarantee of counsel is implicit in Commonwealth v. Hoffman, 426 Pa. 226, 232 A. 2d 623 (1967) (per curiam), and Commonwealth v. Richardson, 426 Pa. 419, 233 A. 2d 183 (1967) (per curiam), which hold such appointment mandatory "in a post-conviction proceeding" on a request by petitioner supported by proof that he lacks the means to procure counsel. In the instant case, the court below properly appointed counsel for petitioner at the initial proceedings but failed to insure counsel's assistance for the subsequent appeal. Although both Hoffman and Richardson specifically concern counsel at the initial stage of the post-conviction procedure,[2] they do direct that counsel be appointed contemporaneously with the filing of a petition containing a request for such appointment. I fail to see how that right can be held to expire after the disposition of the claim by the court below, *208 since the appeal is an absolute matter of right[3] whereas the initial hearing is appropriately granted only when the petition is not "patently frivolous.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit