Supreme Court of Missouri December 31, 1968, 52371 (Black v. Kansas City Southern Railway Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-12-1968
STORCKMAN, Judge.
The plaintiff Charles K. Black sued Charles Glen Fowler and the Kansas City Southern Railway Company for $70,000 for personal injuries received when an automobile owned and operated by the defendant Fowler and in which plaintiff was a
*21
passenger collided with a train of the defendant Railway Company at a grade crossing in the State of Kansas. The verdict and judgment was for the plaintiff and against defendant Railway Company for $25,000 and in favor of the defendant Fowler. The defendant Railway Company, herein sometimes referred to as the Railroad, appealed from the judgment against it and plaintiff appealed from the judgment in favor of defendant Fowler.
The appeals were heard twice in division and then transferred to the court en banc. Prior to the hearing en banc, the plaintiff dismissed his appeal from the judgment in favor of the defendant Fowler. Therefore, on the present submission, we are concerned only with the Railroad’s appeal. In general the Railroad’s contentions are that the plaintiff failed to make a sub-missible case, that there was no showing of proximate cause, that the plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence as a matter of law, that the trial court erred in the giving and refusal of instructions to the jury, in permitting the plaintiff to amend prior to trial, and in refusing to grant a new trial because one of the jurors failed to make a full disclosure on the voir dire examination of the panel. The parties pleaded the law of Kansas as controlling. The plaintiff’s verdict-directing instruction in the alternative submitted two theories of negligence, either that the Railroad failed to sound a timely warning or that it failed to maintain its right of way so as to allow an unobstructed view to oncoming motorists of the movement of its trains approaching the crossing. Portions of a previous opinion rendered in Division One are incorporated herein without the use of quotation marks.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit