Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit January 3, 1968, 18812_1 (Ben Zuke, Trustee in Bankruptcy of Midas Coin Company, Inc., Bankrupt v. St. Johns Community Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-01-1968

PER CURIAM.

This is an appeal by the bankruptcy trustee from final judgment of the District Court determining that St. Johns Community Bank obtained a valid lien superior to that of the bankruptcy trustee

*119

upon United States coins having a numismatic value which were pledged to and placed in possession of the bank as security for a valid loan made to Midas Coin Company, now bankrupt. The Midas Coin Company was in the business of selling rare coins for a profit, and the coins pledged to the bank constituted part of its inventory and stock in trade for sale to customers in the regular course of business.

The problem presented is one of interpretation of the Uniform Commercial Code as adopted in Missouri and in effect at all times here pertinent. The vital issue is whether under the circumstances here presented the filing of a financing statement is required to perfect the bank’s lien. No financing statement was filed. The trial court held that the coins pledged constituted goods in the form of inventory; that the exclusion of money from the definition of goods in § 400.9-105 V.A.M.S. would not apply to coins having a numismatic value which were held as inventory by the coin dealer, and that a valid pledge was made of the coins pursuant to § 400.9-305 V. A.M.S.; hence, under the exception contained in § 400.9-302(1) (a), filing was not required to perfect the bank’s security interest and the lien of the bank upon the coins pledged to it and in its possession as security for the loan made to the bankrupt was a valid lien and took priority to any claim of the bankruptcy trustee.

The close question in the case is whether the money definition in § 400.1-201 (24) V.A.M.S. prevents the transaction here involved from being a valid pledge under § 400.9-305 V.A.M.S.

There are no authoritative decisions in Missouri or elsewhere which pass upon the precise question here presented.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.