Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit July 12, 1968, 18951 (United States v. George Howard Hall and Ruth Hall)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-07-1968

HEANEY, Circuit Judge.

The Fargo Medical Clinic, a co-partnership of thirty-three doctors, established a pension plan for its 165 employees on January 1, 1963.

1

The plan was of the unit benefit type and provided for the vesting of retirement benefits after fifteen years of service and the attainment of age fifty. The plan was approved by the Internal Revenue Service on July 5, 1963.

On October 1, 1963, the Clinic established a pension plan for the partners. It was of the money-purchase variety and provided for immediate vesting.

In 1964, the taxpayer — one of the partners

2

— contributed $2,500 to the partners’ pension plan and claimed a deduction of $1,250 on his 1964 federal income tax return.

In December of 1965, the Commissioner ruled that the partnership plan, when considered with the employee plan, was discriminatory because it provided more liberal vesting provisions for the partners

3

and disallowed the deduction.

4

The taxpayer paid the resulting assessment of $512.50 and filed a claim for a refund. He subsequently instituted this action. The United States District Court for the District of North Dakota held that the partnership plan was not discriminatory and that the taxpayer was entitled to a judgment in the amount of the assessment, plus interest.

The first question is whether a pension plan is discriminatory solely because it provides for immediate vesting for partners and deferred vesting (age fifty and fifteen years of service) for

*385

other employees.

5

We answer this question in the negative.

The government’s position that inequality in vesting, in and of itself, renders a plan discriminatory is posited on its interpretation of § 401 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954,

6

Treasury Regulations

7

and rulings of the Commissioner.

8

The parties state that the question is one of first impression in the courts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.