Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit August 5, 1968, 21121_1 (Rayonier, Incorporated v. F. Arnold Polson)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-08-1968

KOELSCH, Circuit Judge.

This is an appeal by Rayonier, Inc.

1

from an adverse judgment in an action brought in the United States District Court by F. Arnold Poison to recover damages for the alleged wrongful cutting and removal of timber. Jurisdiction of the district court was rested upon diversity of citizenship of the parties.

During 1947, Poison and one Cleveland Jackson, now deceased, entered into a joint venture to buy and sell timber and timberland in and near the Quinault Indian Reservation in Western Washington. Jackson’s position as Chief of the Quinault Indian Tribe made it advantageous for him to deal with the Indians and he did the purchasing while Poison provided the money.

In 1951 Jackson purchased for the venture the undivided one-half interest of Wallace Bumgarner in property known as tho Bumgarner Allotments. This property had been set aside by the government for two Quinault Indian children, Jean and Shirley Bumgarner; on their death during minority their interests passed in equal shares to their parents, Wallace and Nina Bumgarner. Wallace, a non-Indian, had thereupon received a patent for his one-half but, since Nina was an Indian, the government continued to hold hers in trust.

In January 1960, shortly after Nina entered into contract with Rayonier, Inc. to sell to it her interest in the merchantable timber on the Bumgarner Allotments, Jackson executed a similar contract purportedly on behalf of the joint venture.

2

Rayonier, Inc. commenced logging in January 1961 and by July had cut and removed substantially all timber from the property.

Thereafter in August 1962 Poison commenced this suit against Rayonier. His claim in substance was that Jackson lacked authority to sell the timber and that its removal by Rayonier was wrongful. He asserted his claim in the alternative under two Washington statutes, one of which, Wash.Rev.Code Ann. § 64.-12.030, authorizes the allowance of treble damages for timber trespass and the

*914

other, Wash.Rev.Code Ann.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.