Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit September 30, 1968, 9174_1 (United States v. Paul R. White and Anna Lee White)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-09-1968
SETH, Circuit Judge.
This is an action for refund of federal income taxes paid for the calendar years 1959 through 1962, in the amount of $73,600.96. We considered a portion of this same transaction involving the same taxpayers in United States v. White, 311 F.2d 399 (10th Cir. 1962).
The primary issue on appeal concerns the correctness of the trial court’s conclusion that certain royalty payments were taxable as long term capital gain rather than as ordinary income subject to depletion.
The record shows that uranium was discovered on the taxpayers’ fee land in 1953, and they leased it to an individual. The lessee was unable to fully develop the property, and it was concluded that the minerals, together with the mineral lease, should be transferred to Denver-Golden Oil and Uranium Company. Taxpayers so transferred their mineral interest by a mineral deed, which contained
*611
the usual warranties of title, and was in the form of an absolute conveyance of the minerals except coal, oil and gas. This deed, however, retained a royalty to the grantors-taxpayers, but did not require the grantee to develop the property. The taxpayers retained no reversionary rights. The provision as to the royalty reserved to taxpayers reads as follows:
“ * * * a royalty of ten per cen-tum (10%) of the gross value of all minerals mined, marketed and sold from the premises, said gross value being determined by payments received for all ores including bonuses and freight- allowances but after deduction of actual costs of milling, smelting, treatment, cost of transporting the ores, and imposition of penalties of [sic] any; * *
As initial consideration for their transfer, taxpayers received a lump sum payment of $175,000. Taxpayers’ mineral lessee assigned his lease outright to Denver-Golden for a lump sum consideration, and retained no royalty.
At the time the minerals were conveyed by taxpayers, some underground development had been done.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit