Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit September 27, 1968, 12106, 12107 (Gilbert Dalldorf v. Higgerson-Buchanan, Inc., Gilbert Dalldorf v. Higgerson-Buchanan, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-09-1968

combined-opinion

402 F.2d 419 Gilbert DALLDORF, Appellee, v. HIGGERSON-BUCHANAN, INC., Appellant. Gilbert DALLDORF, Appellant, v. HIGGERSON-BUCHANAN, INC., Appellee. No. 12106. No. 12107. United States Court of Appeals Fourth Circuit. Argued May 8, 1968. Decided September 27, 1968. J. Riley Johnson, Jr., and Thomas R. McNamara, Norfolk, Va., (Williams, Worrell, Kelly & Worthington, Norfolk, Va., on brief) for Higgerson-Buchanan, Inc. Morton H. Clark, Norfolk, Va., (Vandeventer, Black, Meredith & Martin, Norfolk, Va., on brief) for Gilbert Dalldorf. Before SOBELOFF, BOREMAN and WINTER, Circuit Judges. SOBELOFF, Circuit Judge: 1 Dr. Gilbert Dalldorf brought an action against Higgerson-Buchanan, Inc., to recover for damages to his sloop, the WANIGAN, sustained when the sloop's mast came into contact with power lines of the Virginia Electric & Power Company passing over a new channel then in the process of being dredged by the defendant. After trial on the issue of liability, the District Court entered an interlocutory decree in which it held both parties guilty of negligence and equally at fault. Since this was an admiralty action, the court applied the doctrine of comparative negligence and awarded the plaintiff one-half of his provable damages. 2 Both parties appealed, each asserting his own freedom from negligence and assigning error to the trial court's findings to the contrary. We affirm the finding that the defendant was negligent but do not sustain the finding of contributory negligence against the plaintiff. 3 On the morning of May 1, 1966, the plaintiff was operating the vessel in the Inland Waterway under power in a northerly direction toward the Elizabeth River. Some distance north of the locks at Deep Creek, he approached a divide in the channel, which looked like the arms of a Y. His chart did not indicate the existence of this divide.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.