Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit November 27, 1968, 12478_1 (Paul Duval Strouth, A/K/A Paul D. Strouth and as Duval Strouth v. C. C. Peyton, Superintendent of the Virginia State Penitentiary)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-11-1968

HAYNSWORTH, Chief Judge:

The District Court dismissed this state prisoner’s application for a writ of ha-beas corpus because of nonexhaustion of state remedies. In the special circumstances of the case we think that a further attempt to exhaust state remedies should be required.

In April 1966, the prisoner sought to attack, principally, a 1958 conviction. He alleged in his petition that he was then serving that sentence, contesting the state’s listing of sentence service then showing him as serving a 1959 sentence. The 1958 sentence underlay a 1963 conviction as a recidivist, which, in passing only, was also attacked.

At the time the petition was filed in the state court there was no known available remedy in the federal courts to attack a conviction to be served in the future.

Coram vobis

was a limited available remedy in the state court, and it was

*538

that writ that the prisoner sought. To the extent that the attack was directed against a sentence, or sentences to be served in the future, the choice was a rational one, but the petition alleged that he was then serving the 1958 sentence, the principal object of the attack.

Virginia’s Supreme Court of Appeals reversed a dismissal of the petition, holding

coram vobis

inappropriate and remanding the case, with directions that the petition be treated as one for habeas corpus. It may be inferred that this remand would have been understood as requiring that the trial court proceed to a determination of the order of sentence service. At that juncture, however, the petition was filed in the district court and the state trial court was requested to continue all further proceedings in that court. This switch may have been influenced by the fact that, a few days before, this court had held federal habeas corpus available for an attack upon successive or consecutive sentences to be served in the future. Rowe v. Peyton, 4 Cir., 383 F.2d 709.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.