Court of Customs and Patent Appeals December 19, 1968, Patent Appeal 8013 (Application of Robert D. Broadley)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-12-1968
WORLEY, Chief Judge.
Broadley alleges reversible error in the decision of the Board of Appeals affirming the examiner’s rejection of claims 1-6
1
as unpatentable over Lewis
2
in view of Midgley
3
under 35 U.S.C. § 103.
The invention relates to a high capacity,
4
low boiling, azeotropic refrigerant composition consisting of difluoro-me thane (CH2F2; boiling point of -51.7° C.) and monochloropentafluoroe-thane (C2F5C1; boiling point of -38.7° C.), as well as to a method of refrigerating using that composition. It appears from the record that azeotropic compositions — ones in which the vapor composition is the same as the boiling liquid composition with which it is in equilibrium — -are advantageous refrigerants compared to non-azeotropic multicomponent mixtures since fractionation or separation of the components of the composition, with attendant increase in condenser pressures and overall loss of efficiency, does not occur during the refrigeration cycle. Appellant’s azeotropic compositions consisting of 30-33 mol % C2F5C1 exhibit a constant, minimum boiling point of -57.3° C., whereas mixtures consisting of 13-65% C2F5C1 have boiling points differing only slightly — about 0.7° C. or less — from that of the azeo-trope. According to appellant, his compositions boil at temperatures lower than the boiling point of either pure component, and thus exhibit a negative deviation from Raoult’s law, an empirical rule to the effect that boiling points and vapor pressures of two-component mixtures vary with concentration between the val
*617
ues for the pure components. It appears that the high capacity of appellant’s compositions relative to that of either component is due to the fact that the compositions are azeotropic and boil at a lower temperature than either component alone,
Olaim lis representative-Vw/IaxIII JL lo X cUl cocil bw L1V v •
, ... 1.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit