Ohio Court of Appeals February 29, 1968, 28520 (National City Bank of Cleveland v. Mitchell)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-02-1968

*142

Corrigan, C. J.

This appeal by the defendants arises out of an action for declaratory judgment brought by the National City Bank of Cleveland, as trustee of the estate of Charles Godman, in the Court of Common Pleas of Cuy-ahoga County. The bank sought a declaration of rights as to who was legally entitled to the proceeds of one portion of that estate, namely, the portion designated for the “lawful issue” of John Godman, son of the settlor. The trial court decided that John Godman’s sons by adoption should not be considered as such “lawful issue.”

The point of decision in this case rests upon the interpretation of Charles Godman’s trust agreement, and especially a 1933 modification of that agreement. In the original trust instrument, executed in 1924, Charles God-man established a life estate for his widow with remainder in income to his two children, John and Helen, in equal shares. After the deaths of John and Helen, the principal from their respective portions was to vest in their “lawful issue.” At that time, John Godman, the son, was thirty-one years old and childless. Later modifications were made in 1926,1929,1933 and 193'5. The first and last changes had no bearing on this case. In 1929, however, the settlor redivided his trust estate in order to provide for the children born to his daughter, Helen. The 1929 modification reduced John’s and Helen’s portions from one-half to two-fifths each and set aside a one-fifth portion for the two grandchildren. In 1933 Charles Godman again modified the trust agreement by changing the shares of his two children from two-fifths to one-third each. By this time John Godman had been divorced from his second wife and was still childless. Then, in 1934, John Godman married his third wife, a widow who had two children, ages seven and four, born to her during her first marriage.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.