Court of Appeals of Kentucky February 2, 1968 (General Truck & Sales Service Co. v. Schlensker)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-02-1968

EDWARD P. HILL, Judge.

This appeal is taken from a judgment entered pursuant to a verdict of $2,409.71 returned by the jury in appellee’s action to recover damages to a diesel truck sustained on March 9, 1964, when the truck was partly submerged by high water from Beargrass Creek, a stream running through the city of Louisville, while in appellant’s possession for repairs.

On or shortly prior to March 3, 1964, a truck belonging to appellee ran off the road near Williamsburg, Kentucky, and sustained damages. Appellee made arrangements with appellant to have a third party tow the truck to appellant’s garage at 927 East Broadway in Louisville for repairs. The truck was parked on a vacant lot near the appellant’s garage. On March 9, 1964, after an all night rain of approximately seven inches, the water from Bear? grass Creek overflowed and flooded a part of the lot on which the truck was located, and from three to four feet of muddy water got into the truck.

Appellant and appellee both rely on Welch v. L. R. Cooke Chevrolet Co., 314 Ky., 634, 236 S.W. 690; and in the interest of consistency, we shall rely upon the same case.

Welch, supra, is a very similar factual case to the one at bar, except in Welch the *389property was damaged by fire instead of by flood as in the present case. The rule in Welch at page 692 is stated as follows:

“In the case of Threlkeld v. Breaux Ballard, Inc., 296 Ky. 344, 177 S.W.2d 157, 151 A.L.R. 708, we adopted the minority view that if a bailor makes out a prima facie case and it appears that the bailed goods were damaged or destroyed by fire, the bailee has the burden of proving that the fire resulted otherwise than from his negligence. This court has not heretofore considered the nature of the proof necessary to meet this burden.”

See also 151 A.L.R. 716.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.