Court of Appeals of Kentucky February 16, 1968 (Collins Co. v. Rowe)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-02-1968

OSBORNE, Judge.

This is an appeal by the Collins Company from a judgment of the Cumberland Circuit Court in favor of Harry Rowe and his wife, Katie, in the total amount of $115,000 for injuries suffered by the appellees as a result of overexposure to carbon monoxide gas. The gas emanated from a gas refrigerator sold by the appellant, Collins Company, to the appellees and installed by them on a houseboat which they owned and kept on Dale Hollow Lake. It is contended upon this appeal that the judgment should be reversed on two grounds: first, that the injury was brought about by an intervening cause which was unusual and not foreseeable by appellant; and, secondly, where no danger exists in a condition which merely makes it possible for an injury to happen through some unrelated cause, the condition itself can not be held as the proximate cause of an injury. The facts surrounding the injury to Mr, and Mrs. Rowe are as follows:

In the spring of 1961, they purchased a houseboat which was equipped with a gas-operated refrigerator. Not being satisfied with the operation of the refrigerator, Mr. Rowe, in an attempt to replace it, called Collins Company which distributed gas refrigerators manufactured by Whirlpool Corporation. As a result of the call, Mr. Rowe learned that Collins did not sell directly to the consumer, but would ship the refrigerator to a Mr. J. D. Coffey, who was its local dealer in Burkesville. At the time Mr. Rowe initially contacted Collins Company, they pointed out to both Coffey and him that the only refrigerator they had in stock was one that had been designed and manufactured to use natural gas and certain parts would have to be exchanged in order to convert it for LP gas use. Rowe agreed to accept the refrigerator under these conditions and Collins agreed to ship it and supply the parts required for conversion. The refrigerator and parts were later shipped directly to Coffey. Shipment was made from the Whirlpool plant in Evansville, Indiana.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.