Court of Appeals of Kentucky February 9, 1968 (Owsley v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-02-1968

EDWARD P. HILL, Judge.

This appeal is from a judgment of conviction for the third violation of the Local Option Law (KRS, Chapter 242), in which appellant was meted a one-year term in Kentucky State Reformatory.

The one ground argued for reversal is that the affidavit for a search warrant, sworn to before a notary public, violates RCr 13.10, and all evidence obtained pursuant to the execution of the search warrant is incompetent and inadmissible.

RCr 13.10, in its entirety, reads as follows :

“A search warrant may be issued, upon affidavit sufficient under Section 10 of the Constitution of Kentucky and sworn to before the issuing officer, by a magistrate, or by any other officer authorized by statute.”

The following footnote appears after the rule above quoted:

“RCr 13.10 is made a part of the rules for the sake of convenient reference, since it is not covered by statute. It is intended merely to restate the common law.”

It is noted that the above section of the Criminal Code provides that a search warrant “may” be issued on the conditions set out therein.

Appellant and appellee both overlooked KRS 242.370, which provides:

“When an officer or or any reputable citizen files an affidavit with any circuit judge, county judge, police judge or justice of the peace, describing premises or a vehicle, where alcoholic beverages are sold, disposed of or possessed in violation of this chapter, the judge or justice shall by his warrant cause the premises or vehicle to be searched for the detection of any alcoholic beverages which are possessed, or kept for disposition, in violation of this chapter.

* * * * ⅜ *

“No search warrant as provided for in this section shall be quashed if it and the affidavit on which it is based are sufficient on the face.”

Our research has revealed that KRS, Chapter 423, relative to the commission, powers, and liabilities of a notary public is as silent as the tomb on the question of the power to administer an oath.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.