Court of Appeals of Kentucky October 18, 1968 (Taylor v. Commonwealth)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-10-1968
DAVIS, Commissioner.
George Taylor, Jr., was tried on two counts of murder arising out of his shooting and killing Eugene and Lloyd Clouse. The jury acquitted him as to the homicide of Lloyd Clouse but found him guilty of voluntary manslaughter of Eugene Clouse and fixed his punishment at confinement in the penitentiary for ten years. In seeking reversal of the judgment Taylor contends (1) that the verdict was grossly inconsistent; (2) that he should have had a directed verdict of acquittal; and (3) that the trial court failed to admonish the jury as to the significance of evidence relating to a previous conviction of felony.
On the night of the shooting Taylor was at an establishment referred to as the “John Holland House” where several other persons including Eugene Clouse were assembled. It was shown that Eugene Clouse was inebriated and had unprovokedly accosted Taylor saying, “Buddy, didn’t I beat your brother about to death?” The proprietor of the Holland House noted Eugene’s aggressive conduct and ordered him to discontinue it. So far as it appears, Taylor made no threats toward Eugene but did respond when Eugene referred to having assaulted his brother by saying, “Yes, but you are not going to do me that way.”
Arnold Bargo was one of the patrons in the Holland House, and he observed Eugene’s actions. Bargo left the premises and brought back with him Lloyd Clouse, brother of Eugene. Bargo explained that *807he had told Lloyd that Eugene “was down there drinking and was in an argument with this Taylor boy.” Lloyd told Bargo that he would go “get him out of there.” Bargo accompanied Lloyd back to the Holland House in Lloyd’s automobile. He said that when they arrived at the Holland House Lloyd got out of the car and directed him to turn the car around and come back to pick up Lloyd and Eugene. Before Bargo could perform this mission, he heard several shots, which proved to be the fatal shots which brought about the deaths of Eugene and Lloyd Clouse.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit