Court of Appeals of Kentucky November 8, 1968 (Day v. Kelsey)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-11-1968

DAVIS, Commissioner.

Treda Day was the unsuccessful plaintiff in a suit for personal injuries allegedly sustained by her when an automobile operated by appellee Kelsey, in which Mrs. Day was a passenger, ran off 1-64 in the nighttime. Mrs. Day appeals, asserting that erroneous instructions were given, and improper argument was made by appellees’ counsel.

About nine o’clock on the morning of September 21, 1964, Miss Kelsey and Mrs. Day left Morehead en route to Lexington. Miss Kelsey did the driving of an automobile belonging to Mrs. Day’s father which Mrs. Day had borrowed from him. After lunching together in Lexington, the two ladies called on a mutual friend, Jerry Proffitt. The three of them went to a restaurant-bar for refreshments. Mrs. Day had a soft drink, but Miss Kelsey consumed some beer, the exact amount not being specified in the record. Being attired in slacks and determining that they would dine in a “nice place,” the ladies purchased some clothing, including skirts, into which they changed at a nearby filling station. Thence, they proceeded to Versailles with Miss Kelsey at the wheel. At a rooming house in Versailles, they met and were joined by two men, friends of Miss Kelsey. The four of them traveled from Versailles toward Frankfort in an automobile operated by one of the men. They dined (and to some extent wined) at a restaurant, although Mrs. Day did not participate in any intoxicating drinks at the restaurant or at all at any time during the entire day and evening. Miss Kelsey drank intoxicants in Lexington, Versailles, and Frankfort, as was known by Mrs. Day.

The party returned to Versailles where Mrs. Day sat in the passenger’s seat of her father’s car while Miss Kelsey talked with one of the men in his car for some two or three hours. For reasons which are not apparent, it was arranged that Mrs. Day would drive her father’s car, following Miss Kelsey in an automobile driven by one of the men until they reached Lexington.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.