Court of Appeals of Kentucky October 25, 1968 (Commonwealth, Department of Highways v. Eberenz)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-10-1968

WILLIAMS, Judge.

In this condemnation action a jury in the Jefferson Circuit Court awarded the appellees Stephen C. Eberenz and Doris M. Eberenz $14,785.00 as compensation for the acquisition of a portion of their property. In its appeal from the judgment entered on that verdict the Commonwealth has set out numerous alleged errors. We will discuss those points which were properly preserved and might recur on a new trial.

Appellees’ property fronts Preston Street Road, in Louisville, a distance of 137.9 feet. The Commonwealth condemned a 13-foot strip across the front. Partially located on that strip was a frame building used as a combination grocery, tavern and living quarters. The taking of the strip necessitated the destruction of the building. A concrete block structure situated near the frame building was not affected by the taking.

The property forms a general “L” shape. It extends back from Preston Street Road more than 200 feet, at which point it turns at right angles to join two lots fronting another street. The lot on Preston Street Road was acquired in 1954 and the other lots were acquired at later dates. The property fronting Preston Street Road is zoned “Commercial” a distance of 200 feet back from the road. The remainder of appellees’ property is zoned “Residential”.

Prior to taking any proof the trial court ruled that only the portion of appellees’ property which is zoned “Commercial” should be considered in making a determination of the value of the entire property. The court found the property to be “ * * physically contiguous and united in ownership but not in use, in that the back portion of said property is not commercially used and cannot be commercially used until the zoning has been changed.” The authority cited is Commonwealth, Department of Highways v. Raybourn, Ky., 359 S.W.2d 611 (1962).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.