California Court of Appeal October 4, 1968, Civ. No. 31594 (Leslie J. Owens Construction. Corp. v. Park)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-10-1968
SHINN, J.*
This is an action to foreclose a mechanic’s lien of $11,845.23 for excavation and grading. The court made findings to the effect that plaintiff contracted to do certain work for $9,000; the work for which plaintiff seeks compensation was a part of the work to be done for that price; plaintiff had been paid $9,000 and that defendants owe plaintiff nothing. Judgment was for defendants and plaintiff appealed.
Plaintiff is a corporation managed by Leslie J. Owens. Cameo Park is a partnership having as its general partners Robert S. Harvey and United Western Lands, Inc.; United Western Lands, Inc., is a corporation; C. Fred Smith is its president. Cameo owned tract 10260, a subdivision of 79 lots in Santa Barbara County. Under contract dated March 21, 1963, Owens Corporation graded the tract, as far as it was staked for grading, for a price of approximately $15,000, which was paid.
It became necessary to raise the proposed level of Patterson Avenue adjacent to the tract, to do certain other excavating and grading work, and a new grading plan was prepared by Holmes, then the engineer for Cameo, which indicated some excavation to be done and the change of levels of practically all the lots. This plan was submitted to plaintiff; Del Sare, then connected with plaintiff, examined the plan, consulted with Holmes, and submitted a bid to United Western, the general contractor, as set out below.1 The bid was accepted by United.
*375The changes of grades of Patterson and Poinsetta Avenues and the Cathedral area mentioned in the bid will be referred to as the change of grade of Patterson avenue. By its bid Owens offered to do the work “required by this change in grades on the basis of the ‘Extra Work’ provision in onr contract dated March 21,1963,” with a ceiling of $9,000.
The determinative issue was stated in the joint pretrial statement as follows: “D.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit