Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York February 16, 1968 (Claim of Vito v. Josall Roofing Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-02-1968

Reynolds, J.

Appeal by the employer and its carrier from a decision of the Workmen’s Compensation Board discharging the Special Fund for Reopened Cases under section 25-a of the Workmen’s Compensation Law from liability. Claimant, a roofer, sustained an accidental injury to his back on June 22, 1956. The last payment of compensation, prior to reopening, was August 27, 1962. Concededly, the board’s order of restoral of May 5, 1966, filed by it “on an application in claimant’s behalf ”, and claimant’s own application to reopen dated May 11, 1966, were filed more than seven years from the date of the *799accident and more than three years from the last payment of compensation. The hoard, however, has found that a report filed by Dr. Buerkle, the attending physician, dated June 4, 1964 and filed June 8, 1964 and thus within the prescribed period, indicated a change in claimant’s condition and therefore constituted a timely application to reopen. The sole question presented here is the propriety of this determination by the board. It is clear that medical reports may constitute an application to reopen even when no formal application is made by the claimant (e.g., Matter of Norton v. New York State Dept, of Public Works, 1 H Y 2d 844). However, this is so only where the report is notice to the board of a change in claimant’s condition (e.g., Matter of McKenna V. Elm Tremont Goal, 9 A D 2d 458). Moreover, as we stated in Matter of Tripoli v. Crucible Steel Co. (12 A D 2d 425, 427, affd. 10 H Y 2d 877): "In determining whether a changed condition is shown, a medical report should not be given a strained or unreasonable interpretation. A doctor, when he makes out these compensation reports, does not realize the possibility of the board’s interpreting them as a changed condition because of the use of some loose language on Ms part.” The report here involved was one of a long series of routine reports filed over several years by Dr. Buerkle.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.