Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 5, 1968 (People ex rel. Doe v. Edwards)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1968

McGivern, J.

The respondent, Spence-Chapin Adoption Service, appeals from a judgment which sustained a writ of habeas corpus obtained by the natural mother of the subject infant and decreed that custody of the infant be awarded the mother.

*65Spence-Chapin is an agency authorized under the statutes to receive the absolute surrender of children for adoption. The relator, the unwed mother of an illegitimate child, had signed a formal writing surrendering the child. At the time of surrender, the mother was 24 years of age. The pertinent statutes, sections 383 and 384 of the Social Services Law, read together, declare that a parent who commits her child to an authorized agency by a voluntary, duly executed and acknowledged surrender instrument ‘ ‘ shall not be entitled to the custody ’ ’ of the child except on a court order ‘ ‘ determining that the interest of such child will be promoted thereby and that such parent is fit, competent and able to duly maintain, support and educate such child.”

The court below has found that at the time of surrender, the mother did not act of her own free will and that the best interests of the child dictate a return to the mother. We cannot agree.

The record does not sustain these conclusions. Quite the reverse: Prior to the birth of the infant on June 22, 1967, the unwed mother had communicated her wishes to Spence-Chapin and made known her plans to place the child out for adoption, in which the putative father concurred. Five days after birth, the infant was physically transferred to the agency. On July 17, 1967, the mother, both her parents, and the putative father, all attended the agency and there she executed the formal document of surrender, in accordance with section 384 of the Social Services Law, authorizing Spence-Chapin to place the child for adoption. The deed was done. It cannot be undone unless judicial scrutiny can find coercion, which we cannot find, or that the best interests of the child dictate a return.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.