Civil Court of the City of New York February 15, 1968 (David v. Manufacturers Hanover Trust Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-02-1968
Thomas R. Jones, J.
On March 4, 1958, plaintiff, James E. David, opened a checking account with the Manufacturers Trust Company, which later became the defendant, Manufacturers Hanover Trust Company. In so doing he affixed his signature to a card, commonly known as a 11 signature card ’ ’, although it bore no title or legend to describe its purpose. However, at the top of the card and above the line for the depositor’s signature were 11 lines of fine print, the 9th and 10th lines of which read:
*1081“ Depositor(s), in any litigation in which the Trust Company and any of them shall be adverse parties, waive(s) trial by jury ”.
On July 1,1960, when Manufacturers Trust Company became Manufacturers Hanover Trust Company, plaintiff indorsed another “ signature card ” at the bank’s request, which also bore no caption or declaration to describe its purpose. Included in the fine print on the second card was a statement that: “In any litigation in which depositor(s) and the Trust Company shall be adverse parties, the Trust Company and depositor (s) waive trial by jury.”
There was also a further provision that on the second document, to wit: “In consideration of the opening and maintenance of this account * * * the Depositor agrees to be bound by, and that this account shall be maintained pursuant to, all the regulations, provisions, conditions and limitations contained in any * * * statement of account * * * used by or for the Depositor ”.
On the reverse side of every monthly statement of account sent to the plaintiff by the defendant thereafter, under the title “Depositor’s Contract ”, was the following statement: “In consideration of the continued maintenance of this account, depositor agrees that: Depositor waives a trial by jury * * * in any litigation in which the Company and depositor shall be adverse parties.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit